Which US airlines do you recommend for domestic service?

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Polite staff, and bad compensation, or the opposite?

This clip is meant to be humorous, I think... ;)


I chuckled, although it's not inaccurate. It was also interesting that they highlighted the North American smile while giving the customer nothing vs. the attitude that (sometimes) comes with European compliance.
 
As the originator of this thread, I thought I would give my thoughts on the three airlines that I used on my recent trip to America.

First up was American, flying from Boston to Chicago. They made the last boarding group, of which I was one, leave their "carry on" bags to go in the hold, and collect from the luggage carousel at Chicago. There was still empty overhead bin space when we took off. Staff were very cold and distant, but got the job done. Flight was a bit delayed, and my seat neighbour was going to miss her connection. Overall a pretty negative vibe.

Next was United, a 777 flight from Chicago to Los Angles. Nicer, large plane, got a free coffee, and happy to have a window seat and no one next to me! The staff seemed happier, and I thought it went well.

Last was two Spirit flights, first from San Diego to Las Vegas, budget carrier, but all went fine, no complaints at all. The second Spirit flight from Las Vegas to Chicago was a different animal... We boarded, pushed back from the gate. Sat, returned to the gate. Pilot said there were "crew time out issues" due to long waits to take off, so we all got off the plane and hung around. Six hours later they said we should be boarding again soon, just need to find one more pilot. Anyway, we did fly to Chicago, arriving after midnight. Riding the Blue line "EL" at that time from O'Hare is not a comfortable experience at my age, guys drinking, smoking blunts, etc... Got to the Hostel safe, but a bit rattled! ;)

My stepdaughter's family flight on British Airways from Las Vegas to London two months ago was delayed by 6 hours, she is expecting compensation of £1500 for that delay.
I asked about compensation at Spirit Airlines, they just said, nothing doing, weather and such. Not even a free cup of coffee on the flight...

All airlines hit snags at times, but I would avoid Spirit in future, a very poor customer service ethos.

I flew to Boston and back with Aer Lingus, I will include that experience when I get around to writing up the full trip report... :cool:
 
Last edited:

My stepdaughter's family flight on British Airways from Las Vegas to London two months ago was delayed by 6 hours, she is expecting compensation of £1500 for that delay.
I am glad you are home safe from your trip, especially the Chicago adventure! I am curious from this statement it appears that British Airways is doing this because of that EU261 law that you all have over there, does the UK still follow it just because, or is there an equivalent UK law requiring reimbursement for late flights?
 
I am glad you are home safe from your trip, especially the Chicago adventure! I am curious from this statement it appears that British Airways is doing this because of that EU261 law that you all have over there, does the UK still follow it just because, or is there an equivalent UK law requiring reimbursement for late flights?
Not specifically EU261 as that ceased to have force in the UK upon Brexit. But the UK did incorporate EU261 rules into their own law, a "UK261", so the result is the same.
 
we
As the originator of this thread, I thought I would give my thoughts on the three airlines that I used on my recent trip to America.

First up was American, flying from Boston to Chicago. They made the last boarding group, of which I was one, leave their "carry on" bags to go in the hold, and collect from the luggage carousel at Chicago. There was still empty overhead bin space when we took off. Staff were very cold and distant, but got the job done. Flight was a bit delayed, and my seat neighbour was going to miss her connection. Overall a pretty negative vibe.

Next was United, a 777 flight from Chicago to Los Angles. Nicer, large plane, got a free coffee, and happy to have a window seat and no one next to me! The staff seemed happier, and I thought it went well.

Last was two Spirit flights, first from San Diego to Las Vegas, budget carrier, but all went fine, no complaints at all. The second Spirit flight from Las Vegas to Chicago was a different animal... We boarded, pushed back from the gate. Sat, returned to the gate. Pilot said there were "crew time out issues" due to long waits to take off, so we all got off the plane and hung around. Six hours later they said we should be boarding again soon, just need to find one more pilot. Anyway, we did fly to Chicago, arriving after midnight. Riding the Blue line "EL" at that time from O'Hare is not a comfortable experience at my age, guys drinking, smoking blunts, etc... Got to the Hostel safe, but a bit rattled! ;)

My stepdaughter's family flight on British Airways from Las Vegas to London two months ago was delayed by 6 hours, she is expecting compensation of £1500 for that delay.
I asked about compensation at Spirit Airlines, they just said, nothing doing, weather and such. Not even a free cup of coffee on the flight...

All airlines hit snags at times, but I would avoid Spirit in future, a very poor customer service ethos.

I flew to Boston and back with Aer Lingus, I will include that experience when I get around to writing up the full trip report... :cool:
Spirit is the US version of Easy Jet and Ryanair without the robust consumer protection laws that exist in the UK and EU. If you wanted to, you could file a complaint with the US Department of Transportation. You won’t get any compensation but Spirit’s chicanery shouldn’t be excused.
 
I just had several flights (and some short amtrak hops) as part of a combined work trip and vacation. I flew several flights with Delta, 1 with American, and 1 with JetBlue. All were great. Delta is probably the best experience - they give out free headphones to everyone, have seat-back TV's, good snacks, etc. I didn't have any issues with American or JetBlue though... JetBlue had a cool little "Pantry" where you could help yourself to extra drinks and snacks - that was cool!
 
As the originator of this thread, I thought I would give my thoughts on the three airlines that I used on my recent trip to America.
Thanks for your thoughts. In my experience AA (American) is getting worse over time. They've been cold and distant toward coach customers for decades but ever since SQ321 they've been abandoning drink and snack service because of "turbulence" that never seems to happen. Oddly this phantom turbulence only prevents coach service and never first class. I have not flown Spirit Airlines myself but I've also never heard anything positive about them. Whenever my flight is near a Spirit gate it always looks like a zoo over there. Crew time out issues are the airline's problem, so you were probably due some minor compensation in the form of snack/drink vouchers, but that's about it. In the US most protections are for bumped passengers, cancelled flights, or getting stuck on the tarmac. If you were brought back to the terminal and you flight eventually took place most of the airline's liability was avoided.

I don't think the concept of "free" exists in Spirit Airlines
Spirit used to be a regular airline decades ago but they have been losing lots of money lately and are talking about bringing full service tickets back again. Supposedly these will include priority check-in, priority boarding, luggage allotments, drink service, and blocked middle seats. Even Southwest is apparently working on implementing assigned seating and some sort of premium service product in the next couple years. I can say I honestly never saw that coming.

JetBlue had a cool little "Pantry" where you could help yourself to extra drinks and snacks - that was cool!
B6's (Jet Blue's) network is a bad fit for most of my trips but I hear good things and it seems like they know how to leverage what they have. They're also one of the few airlines where most of the news is about things they're doing to improve the experience. I was hearing the same things about VX (Virgin America) before AS (Alaska) bought them out and removed everything that made them appealing.
 
Last edited:
Since I don’t fly (on revenue tickets), except occasionally, I dislike all these levels of “priority” that airlines have these days.

I liked it much better in the old days, when it was a much more egalitarian, first come, first served, method of seat selection and boarding.

Sorry they ever started widespread loyalty programs, as they don’t help me that much, but can understand the advantages for those that benefit from them.🤷‍♂️
 
...abandoning drink and snack service because of "turbulence" that never seems to happen. Oddly this phantom turbulence only prevents coach service and never first class.
This is becoming the "catch-all" excuse for no service on shorter flights - even in the front cabin. "The captain is predicting turbulence so the flight attendants will remain in their seats" on several recent flights. Turbulence never materialized and neither did any service. Austrian Airlines and Air Canada are among the repeat offenders. AA did manage to distribute water bottles on a short flight with turbulence, albeit on a small regional jet.
 
We had a very positive experience last week on Breeze Airlines. A low cost carrier but they allow you to bundle features into Nice, Nicer, and Nicest levels.

We probably paid more than we needed to for Nicer (extra leg room, assigned seats, good wi-fi, checked bag. It was worth it for us as it offered non stop service Orlando-Burlington, VT, smaller jet with 2-3 seating (A220). The crew was excellent and on time both ways for a 3 hour flight.

Only drawback was a 7am departure but a Hyatt award night (located in the terminal) solved that and their McCoy restaurant was excellent. Nice approach into Burlington over the Adirondack’s in fall colors and Lake Champlain.

They have some ‘hubs’, like Orlando (with only one gate), but serve smaller airports with less than daily service. It was started by the same guy that started Jet Blue.
 
Since I don’t fly (on revenue tickets), except occasionally, I dislike all these levels of “priority” that airlines have these days.

I liked it much better in the old days, when it was a much more egalitarian, first come, first served, method of seat selection and boarding.

Sorry they ever started widespread loyalty programs, as they don’t help me that much, but can understand the advantages for those that benefit from them.🤷‍♂️
For those who do a lot of flying, it makes a difference - it also feels like spending lots of money on airfare becomes an investment rather than wasted dollars. Not that it ever is wasted as it’s a service… but the feeling remains there.

Moreover, if you are loyal to an airline, and spend a lot of money on them, it makes perfect sense to me that they might be interested in rewarding that loyalty. It’s mutually beneficial for both parties.
 
This is becoming the "catch-all" excuse for no service on shorter flights - even in the front cabin. "The captain is predicting turbulence so the flight attendants will remain in their seats" on several recent flights. Turbulence never materialized and neither did any service. Austrian Airlines and Air Canada are among the repeat offenders. AA did manage to distribute water bottles on a short flight with turbulence, albeit on a small regional jet.
I was recently on a very short flight from Charlotte to Myrtle Beach (29 minutes) on AA’s regional, and they apologized for not serving anything.
But seriously, who needs anything on such a short flight?
Heck, I’ve stood for much longer periods on crowded trains…🤷‍♂️
 
I dislike all these levels of “priority” that airlines have these days.
I would not say that I like buying priority service, but without it I would probably hate what flying as become these days.

This is becoming the "catch-all" excuse for no service on shorter flights - even in the front cabin. "The captain is predicting turbulence so the flight attendants will remain in their seats" on several recent flights. Turbulence never materialized and neither did any service. Austrian Airlines and Air Canada are among the repeat offenders. AA did manage to distribute water bottles on a short flight with turbulence, albeit on a small regional jet.
Yeah I've heard Air Canada's service is almost nonexistent these days. My AA flights still had service up front but nothing in MC. Alaska has started posting website disclaimers that inflight service is being amended or removed on flights to/from Nevada, Arizona, New Mexico and Colorado due to "possible turbulence," although they were still serving drinks and hot meals to NM as of a few weeks ago.

I was recently on a very short flight from Charlotte to Myrtle Beach (29 minutes) on AA’s regional, and they apologized for not serving anything. But seriously, who needs anything on such a short flight? Heck, I’ve stood for much longer periods on crowded trains…
I agree that's not so bad but my last no-service trip on AA was across two flights totaling six hours and because of an AA delay there was no time to get anything in the connecting airport as I ran from the arrival gate to the departure gate. Those flights were booked as MCE which advertises drinks of your choosing as part of the fare but actual service was nothing. When I arrived at my destination everything was shut down and locked up as per the new normal in US airports meaning my first chance to get anything was at a gas station.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top