Search results

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
  1. Urban Sky

    VIA Ocean discussion

    Sure, if you can name any reason why a local government would propose a tax on a corporation which has enormous leverage over it for the exclusive benefit of a different corporation which does not enjoy any such leverage?
  2. Urban Sky

    Proposal for moving VIA Rail out of Saskatoon to Warman

    VIA is not going to do this, as nobody is going to pay for the cost of signalizing and upgrading the Prairie North Line, which is currently „dark territory“ and subject to speed limits of mostly 30 mph or less and sidings far apart. If the province of Saskatchewan was really interested in...
  3. Urban Sky

    Proposal for moving VIA Rail out of Saskatoon to Warman

    According to this response to an ATIA request, there were 4,289 passengers boarding or detraining in CY 2018 at Saskatoon Station: That works out to some 20 passengers per train stopping at the station pre-Covid…
  4. Urban Sky

    VIA Northern Quebec Service

    They usually have one of the 3 HEP-I coaches with a galley you mentioned (8145-47), but that leaves them only one spare, so they will sometimes have to use a HEP-2 coach instead (because none of the other HEP-1 coaches has galleys)…
  5. Urban Sky

    Japan railway firm pushes Maglev plan to 2034 or later

    Intercity Maglevs (or any other technology inherently incomptible with legacy rail or HSR technology) may only ever make sense in either: 1) countries which are obscenely rich, yet have not yet built a significant legacy rail network, or 2) HSR corridors which have reached their capacity limit...
  6. Urban Sky

    Canadian Trip Off Season: Fall or Spring

    I would consider taking the Skeena between Jasper and Prince Rupert in one direction, as it‘s supposedly VIA‘s most underappreciated route…
  7. Urban Sky

    The Canadian Prestige Class - Tipping

    Excessive delays have become drastically less epidemic since the timetable changes of July 2018 and April 2019, which lengthened the trip time and especially the turnaround time in Toronto, and you are now much much more likely to arrive early than late in Toronto or Vancouver. Nevertheless...
  8. Urban Sky

    Amtrak Cascades Service discussion

    Indeed, track maintenance (or at least: inspection) requirements are less for tracks which are not used for passenger movements. Same reason why if a VIA train needs to be exceptionally turned in Ottawa (because of issues with the leading unit, if operated as a bidirectional trainset)...
  9. Urban Sky

    VIA Canadian sleeper questions

    Buffer cars have thankfully only been a thing for the 8 months between mid-October 2022 and mid-May 2023:
  10. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Long Distance (LD) and Inter-Regional fleet replacement

    Unfortunately, the best hint we seem to have to date is a blurry photo in the second picture of this tweet (as discussed over on Groups.io):
  11. Urban Sky

    Can Private Railroads operate passenger service without government help?

    Passenger revenues of the Canadian recovered 102.1% of direct operating costs in 2017 and cost-recovery has rebounded again post-Covid to 78.8% in 2022. This means that the train is very profitable during the summer season (April-October), when the overwhelming majority of passengers travel...
  12. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Long Distance (LD) and Inter-Regional fleet replacement

    I was describing the function of these cars, not the quality of services, amenities (or views) offered on board of them…
  13. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Long Distance (LD) and Inter-Regional fleet replacement

    For RM, which is basically a tourist bus on steel wheels, these all-seats Panorama cars are the only car passengers ever see from the inside, whereas for a rolling hotel like the Canadian, they only serve an auxiliary lounge-and-observation function, as the Sleeper cars themselves are the main...
  14. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Long Distance (LD) and Inter-Regional fleet replacement

    Ontario Northland piggybacking on VIA’s order for another 3 shorter (3-car instead of 5-car) trainsets comes to mind as a model…
  15. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Long Distance (LD) and Inter-Regional fleet replacement

    If you want to procure rolling stock for use on Canadian mainlines, it needs to adher to FRA/TC crashworthiness standards. No active production line in Europe, China or India produces night train rolling stock complying with these standards (as none of their regular customers requires them)...
  16. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Long Distance (LD) and Inter-Regional fleet replacement

    For the purposes of fleet renewals, VIA is faced by the same constraints as Amtrak, not those “the rest of the world operates with”. Given that Tren Maya doesn’t (to the best of my knowledge) share tracks with freight and is not regulated by TC or the FRA, they are not bound to procuring...
  17. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Long Distance (LD) and Inter-Regional fleet replacement

    3 sets (a fourth set was required in summer when the third weekly frequency operated, but it has last operated in 2019). Approximately 10 cars in winter and 20 cars in summer…
  18. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Long Distance (LD) and Inter-Regional fleet replacement

    Again: VIA might need ready-to-deploy Sleeper cars which may act as a stopgap for a few years until the new fleet (hopefully) arrives, not another fleet of cars which first needs massive investments before it is available for service…
  19. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Long Distance (LD) and Inter-Regional fleet replacement

    Acquiring sleeper cars second-hand from Amtrak is one thing, but completely rebuilding cars which have been discarded and were never built for North American specs is an extremely poor use of taxpayer money. Canada should focus on getting the RFP out and the contract signed as soon as possible...
  20. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Long Distance (LD) and Inter-Regional fleet replacement

    No, and the CETA (Canada-EU Trade Agreement) forbids it to errect such trade barriers. However, its national regulator, Transport Canada, usually aligns with its American counterpart (FRA), which all but disqualifies designs from outside North America…
Back
Top