Search results

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
  1. G

    Caltrain looking at Battery Electric MU for Gilroy Service

    These are always or almost always very short sections so large capacity batteries are not required. Such is not the case for San Jose to Gilroy. Charging time could even affect the number of train sets required, and reliability of electrical capacity of the charging stations, should be one on...
  2. G

    Progress of Caltrain Electrification

    I am going to say the following and then shut up on this subject: I am aware of the 110 mph which is primarily for the benefit of the HSR. Each curve is a study of its own. Increased superelevation will almost always require increased spiral (transition from tangent to full radius) lengths...
  3. G

    Progress of Caltrain Electrification

    The ultimate plan is four track, but is probably somewhere in never never land. For now, use existing tracks. Likewise, for some of the grade separations. It is amazing how much NIMBYism comes out, and how irrational some of it is. As to the creeping in the last couple miles, for the San...
  4. G

    Progress of Caltrain Electrification

    Let's assume that 30 mile of the distance could be run at 90 mph instead of 80 mph. It is highly unlikely that much more of the distance could be speeded up sufficiently for the higher speed to be practical: 30 miles at 80 mph = 22.5 minutes 30 miles at 90 mph = 20.0 minutes. That is to say...
  5. G

    Container Ship strikes and collapses Baltimore's Francis Scott Key Bridge

    As has already been said, I see no need nor reason to increase the span width or height opening. Either, particularly vertical clearance would require far more work than simply replacing the existing structure. I also doubt that there is any foundation damage to the pier that was struck. In...
  6. G

    Japan railway firm pushes Maglev plan to 2034 or later

    Avoiding quoting the entire post since it is just above this one. Actually, at 15 trains per hour your chart does not prove your conclusion so far as the Shinkansen is concerned. 142 seconds is still under 3 minutes. Nor am I ready to believe these distances are the absolute floor. 13.8 km at...
  7. G

    The Race to save the Surfliner Route from the Pacific.

    What are some of the reasons? What I have seen so far are mostly NIMBY'isms or somewhat dubious environmental issues. Think some variation of these same things won't happen for any of the relocation plans? If anything they will likely be stronger. There may be some areas where some shifts in...
  8. G

    The Race to save the Surfliner Route from the Pacific.

    Slope protection is neither mystery science nor magic. Use it, posthaste. And while you are at it, make the railroad roadbed wide enough for two tracks and catenary. If my opinion was requested, I would say put the tracks on 22 to 24 feet centers so you could have one row of poles down the...
  9. G

    Japan railway firm pushes Maglev plan to 2034 or later

    With all the excitement about Maglev and its speeds, we must not forget that the laws of physics apply regardless of the method of propulsion. In other words, a 200 mph curve on rails will still be a 200 mph curve if the propulsion is maglev. The rate of change in vertical curves on high speed...
  10. G

    L&N Railroad

    What is the magic about that date? Maybe what you want to know can be found otherwise.
  11. G

    Japan railway firm pushes Maglev plan to 2034 or later

    Even after seeing it is hard to believe the huge volume of people and trains on the existing route. Think big city rapid transit at rush hour. About as much speed as possible has been squeezed out of the exiting route due to curvature and clearances. They have the interesting issue of sonic...
  12. G

    Why are Amtrak California trains on time but long-distance Amtrak trains are delayed?

    If we are talking Sacramento to San Jose, two things initially come to mind: First, the state supported removing the few single track sections, so the route is double track throughout. Second, the line is near dead flat, so freight trains can maintain their speed, so delays due to slow...
  13. G

    Passenger jet pilots fell asleep on flight carrying 159 passengers

    Already on my list of airlines I will not use.
  14. G

    St. Paul, Milwaukee, Chicago (TCMC) second daily service

    The Mississippi River this far north is anything but a Great River. It is a comparatively a small river, little more than a creek to those who live along the true Great Mississippi. The dividing point between the Upper River and the Lower River is the point where the Upper Mississippi River...
  15. G

    Brightline Trains West!

    Concerning the use of European signaling and similar practices: They should be approached with a large dose of skepticism. Many things they do do not work as well as they claim. Many of the US normal practices are more rugged, simpler, and more reliable than their European equivalents.
  16. G

    Brightline Trains West!

    I am a Civil Engineer, and the usual is to gather up all reports and studies that have been done in the area of concern first, and then work out from there. I would be very surprised to find they did not gather all studies that they could get their hands on. Just having existing reports can...
  17. G

    Detroit Peoplemover and Q-Line

    It's made by Lionel, it's swell.
  18. G

    Can Private Railroads operate passenger service without government help?

    ???Not sure of where your V^3 comes into play. I do know it is there, but not at what speed it becomes a consideration. In the Japanese formulae they use V^2 up to 300 km/h, which is as far as they go with any information they let us have. Can't give you their formulae as it is proprietary...
  19. G

    Can Private Railroads operate passenger service without government help?

    When you go to extreme high speeds with freight trains, aerodynamic resistance becomes a major factor in the need for power, and with it extra units to pull the train. In fact, at high speeds aerodynamic resistance is THE major component of train resistance. Since aerodynamic resistance is...
  20. G

    San Clemente landslide affects Pacific Surfliner 1/24/24

    There is nothing inherently wrong with this concept and route, other than its curvature. Flat is a very good thing, and low cost also was a near necessity at the beginning, as for the original we were talking about private money, not government printing press as a source of finance. What is...
Back
Top