Search results

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
  1. sttom

    Colorado Pacific Tennessee Pass Proposal

    I know this is way late, but it got rejected for now https://www.railwayage.com/news/tennessee-pass-revival-on-hold-for-now/ Other reporting https://www.railwayage.com/freight/short-lines-regionals/tennessee-pass-revival-its-complicated/
  2. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    As mentioned before, overnight trains are not just for people going from city center to city center in either terminus. People like me could very easily be traveling from one suburb to another. It’s not like downtowns of major cities have a monopoly on office space. Someone could very easily be...
  3. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    Depends on the railroad and depends on when. Some railroads like the Chicago Great Western figured they'd be on the short end of the stick in 1945 and others didn't face problems until much later. The UP and BN were such examples of facing problems later. From what I can tell, people say there...
  4. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    Financial gold mines, no. Less money losing and small profit, potentially. Railroads didn't even want to try to compete in the 50s and were happy to cede as much of the market as they could get away with by and large until Amtrak was created. Some railroads figured in the 30s that cars would be...
  5. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    "Died" really isn't the right term to describe what happened to the easy overnight trips in the US rail network prior to Amtrak. A lot of companies (notably the Southern Pacific and the Chicago & Northwestern) ran their trains into the ground in a bid to get rid of them because they didn't want...
  6. sttom

    Amtrak goes straight to STB to restore Gulf Coast service.

    The main issue with Amtrak's beginning is that it's manadated to maintain a national network to provide a balanced transportation system, but there is and was absolutely no definition of what that would mean in practice. And to this day there is no discussion on what that would mean as far as...
  7. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    This isn't an exhaustive list: New York - North Carolina DC - Atlanta DC - Cincinnati Chicago - St Paul Chicago - Nashville Chicago - Fort Worth Chicago - Denver Denver - Fort Worth Denver - Salt Lake City Denver - Albuquerque Denver - St Louis Kansas City - St Paul Los Angeles - Tucson Los...
  8. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    People bought or made their own wagon back then, it's not like they strolled down to Enterprise to rent one. Also, roads are generally owned by the public, the railways largely aren't. Railways are not obselete, shoving 90% of trips into cars is not healthy. Expanding highways is like solving...
  9. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    You still can, with 90% less dysentery. You'd just have to get a horse, wagon and consult a map.
  10. sttom

    Hypothetical High Platform Superliner Replacements

    Their either going to figure out you can do level boarding at 25 inches or make everyone do a stair lift to 48 inches and reduce capacity. Those are your two options.
  11. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    We can't have good transit cause something something self driving cars.
  12. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    My point is also getting at the notion that there are more City pairs where this works than just New York and Chicago. Also, if you're working so late with other people on a day you know you're traveling up until a 7pm departure time, that's on you for being bad at time management, not Amtrak's...
  13. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    A 12 hour trip also isn't terrible for an overnight hop. The train leaving the terminal stations at 7pm for a 7am arrival wouldn't break the bank time wise. Especially if you live in a suburb around a big city and are on the opposite side of the airport. I would use such a train to get to LA if...
  14. sttom

    A Silver at South Station

    There is also the kill joy who thinks pointing out Amtrak needs new equipment is a got ya and not just basically everyone's assumption at this point.
  15. sttom

    Auto Train service expansion?

    I personally think Auto Trains outside of the one we already have could work, but it would probably be seasonal for the most part and would need to be run as a separate train. I do think the Zephyr could sustain a summer season Auto Train with stops in Northern California, Salt Lake City...
  16. sttom

    Route Guides

    I follow this couple on YouTube and they run a blog that talks a lot about Amtrak and their other travels in the US. https://www.groundedlifetravel.com/
  17. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    Another thing that also needs to be factored in isn't just time, but distance. As I have pointed out a few different times, the average long distance trips we take are between 100 and 300 miles with respects to ground transportation. These distances are generally too short to fly and depending...
  18. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    Politics can and are changing, the question that remains to be seen is if that will have an effect on Amtrak in any way. Amtrak's leadership is all talk as far as I'm concerned until I see results. Their 2035 "plan" shows how unimaginative they are. They can say they want a NightJet product...
  19. sttom

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying?

    Why aren't overnight trains able to compete with flying? My first point would be that Amtrak's network isn't dense enough to provide effective overnight service between most cities in this country. For a city pair to be fruitful as a pair, they need an 8 to 12 hour end to end run time. Amtrak...
  20. sttom

    Significant former routes

    The North Coast Limited ran the Northern Pacific route, so not the Empire Builder. The Empire Builder doesn’t run where most the people live. Los Angeles to Chicago already has plenty of service, (at least by Amtrak standards) there is not really a reason to add a new route to this. Amtrak...
Back
Top