Search results

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
  1. Urban Sky

    Canadian "Buffer Cars" discussion

    Eric Gagnon’s Blog is called “Trackside Treasure” (no plural) and the report which recommended the Buffer Car measure can be found here: http://tracksidetreasure.blogspot.com/2022/11/the-report-that-hatched-buffer-cars.html?m=1
  2. Urban Sky

    Canadian "Buffer Cars" discussion

    There are three plausible regulatory approaches when encountering that something might no longer comply with applicable safety regulations: 1) Ignore the issue until more definite evidence is found. 2) Accept mitigating measures until more definite evidence is found. 3) Immediately suspend...
  3. Urban Sky

    Canadian "Buffer Cars" discussion

    Yes, 6208 (an RDC-2) was sacrificed: https://groups.io/g/Canadian-Passenger-Rail/message/95897 If I read my Canadian Trackside Guide Correctly, that leaves only 1 RDC-1 (6105), 2 RDC-2s (6217&6219) and 2 RDC-4s (6250&6251) in VIA’s active roster…
  4. Urban Sky

    Canadian "Buffer Cars" discussion

    Even though they put the RDCs from Vancouver Island (i.e. the only other RDC which operated past the 1990 cuts) into storage, they no longer have enough RDCs to operate multiple consists, let alone: multiple services without a shared base… It’s not a question of how “safe” the trains are, but...
  5. Urban Sky

    Canadian "Buffer Cars" discussion

    As I explained elsewhere, VIA barely has enough RDCs left to operate this service (but they would have of course kept more if there had been any other RDC services left): I believe the logic goes that it was questionable whether these cars still provided the mandated crashworthiness and that...
  6. Urban Sky

    Canadian "Buffer Cars" discussion

    They had to run the RDCs in triples, as passengers would only be allowed on the middle RDC…
  7. Urban Sky

    Minimum adequate service in Western Canada

    You are correct, though direct Montreal-Vancouver service of course briefly reemerged between June 1985 and January 1990. Here the November 1981 schedules of the replacement trains for the cancelled transcontinental services: Ottawa-Sudbury (indeed only 3 trains per week): Capreol-Winnipeg...
  8. Urban Sky

    Western Canada forest fires

    If there is one vehicle with which I definitely wouldn’t want to enter a wildfire area, it would be a train: Can‘t just turn around, can‘t just take a detour…
  9. Urban Sky

    Western Canada forest fires

    Apparently, a bus bridge was put in place by VIA, to cover the gap between Jasper and Edmonton: https://groups.io/g/Canadian-Passenger-Rail/topic/98735335
  10. Urban Sky

    Minimum adequate service in Western Canada

    Agreed, I dropped SSM and converted Toronto-Sudbury-Thunder Bay-Winnipeg into a night train. As you can see, the TRTO-WNPG night train's estimated ridership potential is not even twice that for LNDN-SARN and it feeds almost exclusively (94%) from Toronto-centric traffic: I would assume that...
  11. Urban Sky

    Minimum adequate service in Western Canada

    Under the current schedule, the Canadian departs Vancouver at 15:00 on Day 1 and spits you out in Vancouver almost exactly 4 days later, with a minimum fare of $549 in Economy Class: With a connection of day trains, you would depart Vancouver in the morning and arrive in Toronto 6-and-a-half...
  12. Urban Sky

    Minimum adequate service in Western Canada

    I don’t know if they briefly dropped the name, but I always thought they took pride in running the oldest named train in North America. In any case, I received this Email from them today, where they still call it “the Ocean”:
  13. Urban Sky

    Minimum adequate service in Western Canada

    Can’t check my timetable database right now, but VIA stopped naming their Corridor trains in 1997 (IIRC) and its Remote trains soonafter, leaving only the Canadian and the Ocean. I don’t know when they dropped the name for the Ocean, but that must be a very recent change…
  14. Urban Sky

    Minimum adequate service in Western Canada

    Thank you, my intention was to show that even though there are a lot of different objectives you can achieve with a once-daily schedule, many of them are unfortunately mutually exclusive and therefore you are stuck with painful tradeoffs which decimate whatever markets you can actually serve...
  15. Urban Sky

    Minimum adequate service in Western Canada

    Greg Gormick is without a doubt one of the most prolific railway historians on this side of the border, but just to highlight the "quality" of his recommendations: In Section 5.2.3 of his 1-4-10 plan, he estimates that "the construction of a 42-mile Smiths Falls Gananoque cutoff [...] would...
  16. Urban Sky

    Minimum adequate service in Western Canada

    I sense some kind of consensus here that VIA ought to operate Toronto-Winnipeg, Winnipeg-Calgary-Vancouver, Winnipeg-Edmonton-Vancouver, Regina-Saskatoon and Edmonton-Calgary at-least daily. Let's ignore Edmonton-Calgary for now, but as someone who has been lucky enough to get exposure to the...
  17. Urban Sky

    Minimum adequate service in Western Canada

    To put things into perspective: Toronto & Winnipeg are approximately 1500 km (950 miles) apart, the same distance as Munich-Istanbul, Boston-Atlanta or Seattle-Los Angeles. The only relevant population centres along the CP route are Kenora (15k), Thunder Bay (123k) and Sudbury (171k) with a...
  18. Urban Sky

    Minimum adequate service in Western Canada

    I‘ve never heard of any such plans, but would be very curious to learn more about them!
  19. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Canadian and the Canadians

    Even though everything East of Manitoba is commonly referred to as “Eastern Canada”, the on-train crew members (OTS) are the same which work the entire route from Toronto to Vancouver (though they are replaced by a fresh crew at Winnipeg), just like the overwhelming majority of Sleeper Plus...
  20. Urban Sky

    VIA Rail Canadian and the Canadians

    I recall that VIA opened a base for On-Train Staff in Ottawa maybe 5 years ago, given their struggle to attract enough candidates in Toronto which would be sufficiently fluent in both official languages and willing to work on the salary of a public-sector service job. I don’t want to know how...
Back
Top