I'm not going to lie, I'm very very disappointed that this autumn express leaves before the first scheduled train from NYP can even arrive at Albany. That seems a little counter productive to me.
I live in NYC, I don't have a car. I might change my mind, but right now I don't have a desire to spend $300+ on this trip. Last year, leaving from a densely travelled rail station was perfect. Amtrak could have at least had the departure AFTER there was an arrival. They'd even make more money for themselves.
Send them an email via Amtrak.com and ask that it be forwarded to Autumn Express planning. They do listen to the feedback and you have legitimate points. Unfortunately darkness falls so soon in October and I'd like to see this trip run in September instead.
When the idea of an Autumn Express for 2015 was floated, there were multiple trips explored. Most did not come to fruition for various reasons. That being said, the trips operate with certain things in mind including but not limited to host railroad cooperation, crew availability, equipment availability and the means to service it.
While it may seem like a no-brainer to operate it after connecting trains have a chance to arrive, what does that do to the rest of the trip? Perhaps the host railroad stated that things need to wrapped up by a certain time. Perhaps ALB stated that if the equipment arrives back in the evening after a certain hour, they will have difficulty servicing it due to conflicts with revenue trains. Perhaps the pilots of the route need to be finished by a certain time or the host railroad won't offer them.
There are so many scenarios and variables. Look at the impact of the lower corridor. To support this train and another special, the Acela sets are being pressed into additional duty, which reduces maintenance windows. Trains are skipping scheduled stops while other trains are making additional stops.
It takes a lot of coordination and effort to make these trips and sometimes not everyone will be accommodated. I am glad people are considering hotels and alternate means to take this trip. It makes it worthwhile.