Girl sticks head out of train window, narrowly missing oncoming train

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

DET63

Conductor
Joined
May 6, 2009
Messages
1,777
A video that appears to show a smiling train passenger narrowly miss being hit by an oncoming train while sticking her head out the window is making the rounds online.
In a harrowing, 30-second video, the girl—identified as Carissa—is encouraged by a fellow to stick her head out the moving train for a photo and video shot from a window a few seats away.
Link

A few comments:

  • Their voices sound like Americans.
  • The train seems to be running on jointed rail.
  • The oncoming locomotive doesn't appear to be one used on American trains (except maybe on electric trains in the NEC, but I don't think this is the NEC).
  • The girl's name appears to be Krista, not Carissa, as claimed in the article.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
A video that appears to show a smiling train passenger narrowly miss being hit by an oncoming train while sticking her head out the window is making the rounds online.
In a harrowing, 30-second video, the girl—identified as Carissa—is encouraged by a fellow to stick her head out the moving train for a photo and video shot from a window a few seats away.
Link

A few comments:

  • Their voices sound like Americans.
  • The train seems to be running on jointed rail.
  • The oncoming locomotive doesn't appear to be one used on American trains (except maybe on electric trains in the NEC, but I don't think this is the NEC).
  • The girl's name appears to be Krista, not Carissa, as claimed in the article.
The train is not Amtrak. Windows do not open like this on any Amtrak rolling stock. Also, good job with sensationalizing the video with a shocking title. In reality, trains on adjacent tracks never run so close that a person's head sticking outside would be taken by train on adjacent track. Scary? Yes. Foolish? Yes. "Almost killed"? Naah.
 
I wouldn't be so bold as to say "never".

From another thread discussing track spacing:

George. Thanks! As usual very good info.

Track centers in NJ at present are 12' to 12.5'. Volpe research suggests that aerodynamic issues are manageable at 12.3'. Greater problem as far as safety case goes has to do with interference due to derailment or shifted load in freight. One significant possibility being considered is temporal separation of freight on NEC to address it partly, though the general derailment interference issue is not wholly addressed. In any case the whole thing is about mitigation and probabilities. So we'll see where it all goes. It sounded very much like they will settle for something like 13' to 14' at the end of the day on existing RoW. That in and of itself will take considerable amount of wetland mitigation apparently given where a lot of the current RoW is. And then there are other odd problems like communicationc able easments along the Row that could need to be moved etc.
To have built at 12 feet at any time is simply nuts. To give a prespective, the various freight car "Plates" are all 10'-8", which usually means about 10 feet over the body. The Amtrak clearance diagram is 10'-6", presumably over grab irons, and 10'-0" over what I suspect as being the body. The Dynamic Outlne, in otherword the limit of sway, etc. is 11'-4". That doesn't leave much air between trains. Think of the standard highway lane as being 12 feet wide and the maximum truck width without permits as being 8'-6".
 
I agree "never say never"! There was a conductor (who should have known better) that stuck his head out the window - and it hit a bridge!
ohmy.gif
I don't think he's riding trains any longer - he may be 6 feet under instead!
 
Some people are saying this was filmed in Italy. If you go here and scroll down there are freeze frames of the oncoming train:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2217942/Heart-stopping-video-shows-girl-narrowly-escape-decapitated-speeding-train.html?ITO=1490

Compare the logo on the front of the engine to the logo of Italian railways:




It's not a slam-dunk comparison as the video clip is very shaky, but seems as likely as anything else. But yeah, Americans on holiday not using

their head...there's a first for everything, I guess. :rolleyes:
 
If you act like a fool and your head gets knocked off, you had it coming to you.
 
The train is not Amtrak. Windows do not open like this on any Amtrak rolling stock. Also, good job with sensationalizing the video with a shocking title. In reality, trains on adjacent tracks never run so close that a person's head sticking outside would be taken by train on adjacent track. Scary? Yes. Foolish? Yes. "Almost killed"? Naah.
The train is Italian.
 
The train is not Amtrak. Windows do not open like this on any Amtrak rolling stock. Also, good job with sensationalizing the video with a shocking title. In reality, trains on adjacent tracks never run so close that a person's head sticking outside would be taken by train on adjacent track. Scary? Yes. Foolish? Yes. "Almost killed"? Naah.
The train is Italian.
Does that Italian train have air-conditioning? I know many do but that train had windows that could open.
 
Back
Top