I'm afraid that you're right, since my wife's Triple Play promo points posted on 1/23 as well, and she never pursued them.
Thats the frustrating thing- I do not want to seem like a jerk, and have to call AGR. I have the patience of an elephant, and would wait however long it takes.... as long as I knew it would show up eventually. But somethings never show up for me (like Bustitutes, and commuter passes, for example).
The mall, though, is not much different then the various "Free Ipod" programs that have been around the internet for 10+ years. I remember doing the freedvd,com thing back in 2000. Had a similar "mall", and you got free dvds instead of travel points. It was always a struggle to get points to post for free DVDs because it was up to the 3rd party to post back.
So I'll pursue the rail points, but the mall points.... just doesnt seem worth the effort.