It probably would be easier to go to Chicago and take the Southwest Chief
I got the impression, perhaps mistakenly, that the original poster was looking for public transportation options and had no plans to rent a car (otherwise why would they have asked the question in the first place.) Going to Chicago on the City and then to Flagstaff on the Southwest Chief is a long but reasonable option if flying and bus connections are not workable.How is that easier? I’ve made similar trips countless times and they never once involved a detour to/near Chicago (or LA). Unless riding the train trumps all other potential considerations I would recommend renting a car like any other sensible person. Arizona is a beautiful state but a surprising number of the people who actually live there are proudly retrograde and the public transportation options have been severely lacking for as long as I can remember.
Google Maps tells me your choices are: hitchhike; rental car; fly.
Sounds to me like the main purpose of Margo's trip is to see the Grand Canyon. That little train from Williams to the Grand Canyon Village will deposit you at the Western entrance to the park. But there are things to see all along the 22 mile stretch of road to the Eastern park entrance. And as a Yooper, I found a 6 to 8 mile stretch of AZ 64 East of the parks East entrance also had breathtaking views of the rims of the Little Colorado River Gorge. Oh - there's also a 7-8 mile paved dead end road out to the Western extremity of the park which makes the total distance driven to see just the really scenic things about 57 miles - 20 of it outside the Eastern park entrance.
None of that can be seen from any train. Some of it might be seen from a tour bus. All of it can be seen from a rental car. And all of it can be seen by those up to a 35 mile walk.
I drove the loop from Flagstaff into the East entrance and out the West entrance in 2014. The drive South out of the West entrance was anticlimatic. The only high point of that leg of the trip was the McDonald's restaurant in Tusayan where classical music was on the PA system to (as the manager back then said) "Keep the kids out". Seemed to do the job quite well.
Enter your email address to join: