Ticket Question

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Feb 4, 2025
Messages
3
Location
pennsylvania
Hi All,
I am new here. I recently booked a round trip ticket online. I got a great price and was really excited about my trip. Something came up and I need to change my departure to an earlier time.
Imagine my surprise when I go online and it says I can't do that!! Come to find out my tickets are value rate tickets and you cannot change the date or time! WHY??? I am willing to pay the difference if there is one! This is crazy!!
I can't cancel either because I would have to pay a 25% cancel fee!!

This is unbelievable!! Is there anything else I can do??? I really need to leave earlier.
TIA
 
Nope, not without sacraficing 25% of your intial ticket value. (This is better than the cheapest airline tickets that don't let you change the tickets at all).

I normally spend the few extra dollars and book the more expensive Flexible tickets so I can change my plans and departures (I do this fairly frequently actually), or just cancel if I need too.
 
If I had realized ALL the restrictions I would have booked the more expensive ticket. I just don't understand what they are gaining by not letting me change the time! Makes no sense to me!!

What happens if I bid to upgrade and get it, then can I change the time?
 
What happens if I bid to upgrade and get it, then can I change the time?
No. Your bid would be for the departure you are currently ticketed on.

If I had realized ALL the restrictions I would have booked the more expensive ticket. I just don't understand what they are gaining by not letting me change the time! Makes no sense to me!!
Haven't you ever bought an airline ticket? Restricted "discount" fare tickets are neither new nor unusual. They are pretty much the standard and have been for decades. Amtrak just follows common industry practice with discount ticket restrictions and dynamic, yield managed pricing.

Amtrak, in point of fact, is less restrictive than most airlines. The 25% penalty is low compared to airlines. Flexible tickets are usually only a little more expensive than Value fares, as opposed to the huge difference in airline fares between restricted discount fare classes and full fare, unrestricted "Y" class coach.

Next time pay the modest difference Amtrak charges between Value and Flexible.

For now, either pay the 25% penalty and reticket or take the train you are currently ticketed on. Your choice.

You may find that an agent may be more flexible by calling to modify the ticket rather than doing it online.
 
Last edited:
PS, the difference in terms between Value and Flexible is presented in a crystal clear fashion in the online purchase dialog prior to finalizing the purchase. It is totally up front and not buried in fine print. Screenshot_20250205_103438_Chrome.jpg

So, no I really cannot imagine your surprise. There really isn't any excuse for pleading the 25% cancellation penalty and no changes was in any way a surprise.

Me? I'd pay the four bucks.
 
Last edited:
Haven't you ever bought an airline ticket? Restricted "discount" fare tickets are neither new nor unusual. They are pretty much the standard and have been for decades. Amtrak just follows common industry practice with discount ticket restrictions and dynamic, yield managed pricing.

Depends on the airline. Southwest has no change fees regardless of the ticket type. Heck - once I even found a cheaper fare for the same flight and manage to get a credit. United doesn't have change fees for most fare categories, but for Basic Economy they still allow for same-day standby to get on an earlier flight.
 
Depends on the airline. Southwest has no change fees regardless of the ticket type. Heck - once I even found a cheaper fare for the same flight and manage to get a credit. United doesn't have change fees for most fare categories, but for Basic Economy they still allow for same-day standby to get on an earlier flight.
Yes, I have been able to get credit for cheaper fares on airlines as well.

However, many airlines do not allow for changes with their lowest (saver fares). For all intents and purposes (I.e. for everyday fares), the "Value" fare on Amtrak is the airline equivalent to a "saver" fare.

(Yes, I'm aware Amtrak does have a "Sale" fare now, which has a 50% cancelation fee, but those only pop up when Amtrak actually runs a sale, thus not a fare you can purchase everyday).
 
Yes, I have been able to get credit for cheaper fares on airlines as well.

However, many airlines do not allow for changes with their lowest (saver fares). For all intents and purposes (I.e. for everyday fares), the "Value" fare on Amtrak is the airline equivalent to a "saver" fare.

(Yes, I'm aware Amtrak does have a "Sale" fare now, which has a 50% cancelation fee, but those only pop up when Amtrak actually runs a sale, thus not a fare you can purchase everyday).

Sure. But airlines as a rule have some pretty onerous cancellation policies unless one pays full fare. And full fare for most airlines is a heckuva lot more than Amtrak's idea of full fare. I remember trying to price that once when I thought I might need the flexibility and the fare was something like 5x the current nonrefundable fare.

Gone are the days when all Amtrak trips (paid with cash or an eVoucher) could be cancelled with 100% of the fare back as an eVoucher. I didn't do that often. Might have done it once with a ticket booked with a promo code. Maybe another time when I never got checked (and I wasn't hiding) by a conductor for the entire ride on an unreserved route. Several conductors said I was free to do whatever I wanted with an unscanned ticket. I didn't ride that route much so I got an eVoucher right at Quik-Trak (went back to my account since I booked online). I used the credit to ride later on.
 
Back
Top