Which US airlines do you recommend for domestic service?

shop deals on amazon
Advertise with us
Shop deals on ebay
Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Devil's Advocate said:
For the most part the domestic airline market is won or lost on routes, frequencies, times, prices, and status rather than service.
Click to expand...
Indeed, my comment was more about the Jeb Brookes Youtube video, which was trying to compare the service and experience between three broadly very similar products... Nothing in the video would make me choose one over the other, but no doubt it generated a bit of income for Mr. Brookes. ;) :cool:
 
I am flying for the first time since 2008 in October to the west coast. I normally prefer doing Amtrak and don’t like flying but I can’t afford to use the required time off this particular trip and really want to go. I am doing Alaska out and JetBlue back. What is your take on seat comfort with these and are the “more room” coach seats worth it? I may spring for a business upgrade if one is available - but didn’t want to pay the full up front cost.
 
lordsigma said:
I am doing Alaska out and JetBlue back. What is your take on seat comfort with these and are the “more room” coach seats worth it? I may spring for a business upgrade if one is available - but didn’t want to pay the full up front cost.
Click to expand...
If you're tall the extra pitch can be worth every penny and you get a few other benefits like earlier boarding, easier luggage stowing, and free drinks.* In the case of Alaska Airlines the First Class pitch is not that different from Premium Class but the width is greater and you can pre-book a meal between two weeks and 24 hours. Alaska is one of the few (only?) airlines who still use full galleys on regional aircraft so even Horizon flights can include hot meals in First. Be aware that if you do not pre-book (or you upgrade day-of) there may be no meals available. This includes plated meals in First and purchasable snacks in Premium. I have never flown JetBlue so I cannot speak to that experience.

*The exception among US legacies is United Airlines where you only receive the increased pitch and nothing else.
 
Last edited:
Devil's Advocate said:
If you're tall the extra pitch can be worth every penny and you get a few other benefits like earlier boarding, easier luggage stowing, and free drinks.* In the case of Alaska Airlines the First Class pitch is not that different from Premium Class but the width is greater and you can pre-book a meal between two weeks and 24 hours. Alaska is one of the few (only?) airlines who still use full galleys on regional aircraft so even Horizon flights can include hot meals in First. Be aware that if you do not pre-book (or you upgrade day-of) there may be no meals available. This includes plated meals in First and purchasable snacks in Premium. I have never flown JetBlue so I cannot speak to that experience.

*The exception among US legacies is United Airlines where you only receive the increased pitch and nothing else.
Click to expand...
I think I am going to purchase premium on the Alaska flight - thanks for the info!
 
lordsigma said:
I am flying for the first time since 2008 in October to the west coast. I normally prefer doing Amtrak and don’t like flying but I can’t afford to use the required time off this particular trip and really want to go. I am doing Alaska out and JetBlue back. What is your take on seat comfort with these and are the “more room” coach seats worth it? I may spring for a business upgrade if one is available - but didn’t want to pay the full up front cost.
Click to expand...
JetBlue is an excellent airline from a comfort perspective. Their regular coach seats have at least 32 inches of pitch and all are 18 inches wide. JetBlue also offers free, fast WiFi throughout the flight and every seat has an amazing seat back entertainment system. If you are flying to the west coast you may be on a flight that offers Mint, which is their “business” class service. It offers lie flat seats, free meals and drinks, and exceptional service. There are however some drawbacks to JetBlue. Most of their flights do not have Mint, even when flying cross country. And most importantly, they have a terrible operational reputation. Their flights are regularly delayed and they do not have the ability to put you on another carrier. On a lot of routes they only fly once or twice a day so if your flight is severely delayed they will not present many options for you. I’m sorry for the novel but as someone that lives in New England I have a lot of experience with JetBlue.
 
That's my concern with JetBlue as well.... American, United, and Delta have issues, but they run so many planes they can usually get you where you need to go. My one experience flying JetBlue was great though - very friendly attendant, comfortable seats. They gave coach passengers individual bottles of water throughout the flight.
 
Alaska is solid. Premium Economy class is a bit more legroom, so for nonstop transcontinental flights it may be worth to buy up. Sometimes First class is not much more than economy depending on the fare buckets. Alaska may not run a lot of transcontinental flights so be mindful of service recovery to/from the east coast, though they are now partnered with OneWorld so they can push you onto an American flight (for better or worse!).

I've only flown JetBlue once but that was well before they went the ultra-low-cost carrier route. Keep in mind that service recovery is often terrible with JetBlue, especially if your only flying options are from JFK or Boston to your destination.
 
Last edited:
I would suggest you check out "SeatGuru". You can pull up specific pitch and width dimensions for specific airlines and their various aircraft, and if you know your actual aircraft model once you've chosen a flight, you can see which specific seats have advantages or potential disadvantages.
 
pi314 said:
I would suggest you check out "SeatGuru". You can pull up specific pitch and width dimensions for specific airlines and their various aircraft, and if you know your actual aircraft model once you've chosen a flight, you can see which specific seats have advantages or potential disadvantages.
Click to expand...
SeatGuru was way out of date and not being updated. Has that changed recently?
 
jis said:
SeatGuru was way out of date and not being updated. Has that changed recently?
Click to expand...
Apparently TripAdvisor ran out of cash and cut the original creator loose leaving the site to die. What's funny is that with C19 going on I did not even notice the change until years later when the mismatches and missing entries started becoming obvious and repetitive. It was just so ingrained in my trip planning.

Link: https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/travel/seat-guru

I've tried using https://www.aerolopa.com/ as a replacement but it's not the same. Maybe https://seatmaps.com/ is better.

It was just so easy plugging "AA 738 seats" into google and immediately being within a click or two of the information you wanted.
 
caravanman said:
Hi Folks,

I am visiting the USA this September, and for the first time ever, I am thinking of incorporating some flights, rather than Amtrak rides only.

Is there anything to know, or to choose between the budget airlines? I am seeing options such as Spirit, Allegiance, Alaska, etc.

One tends to go for just lowest price at my end of the market, but is one carrier much less reliable, etc etc?

Thanks!

Ed.
Click to expand...
My personal opinion is that if you're used to the likes of Ryanair, even the most spartan US carrier is luxury and highly customer-focused in comparison.
 
Devil's Advocate said:
Apparently TripAdvisor ran out of cash and cut the original creator loose leaving the site to die. What's funny is that with C19 going on I did not even notice the change until years later when the mismatches and missing entries started becoming obvious and repetitive. It was just so ingrained in my trip planning.

Link: https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/travel/seat-guru

I've tried using https://www.aerolopa.com/ as a replacement but it's not the same. Maybe https://seatmaps.com/ is better.

It was just so easy plugging "AA 738 seats" into google and immediately being within a click or two of the information you wanted.
Click to expand...
Good to know. Looks like seatmaps is the way to go.
 
This was a fascinating thread to read, and it’s clear opinions run deep regarding airlines.

The reality, as I see it (I fly >40,000 miles a year for work), is that for the average person, whatever that means to you, the vast majority of flights on all major, non budget, US carriers will be the same - with only minor differences here and there.

And no, I don’t see huge differences in quality of economy seating product when comparing similar tiered domestic and international airlines.
 
Last edited:
Tlcooper44 said:
The reality, as I see it (I fly >40,000 miles a year for work), is that for the average person, whatever that means to you, the vast majority of flights on all major, non budget, US carriers will be the same - with only minor differences here and there.
Click to expand...
In general terms I think many travelers realize that Allegiant, Frontier, and Spirit are in one group, with American, Delta, and United in another, and Southwest doing their own thing. Like you I'm doubtful they can articulate what is different between airlines within each group or how they compare with B6 or AS.

Tlcooper44 said:
And no, I don’t see huge differences in quality of economy seating product when comparing similar tiered domestic and international airlines.
Click to expand...
AA, AS, & DL have a better domestic W/Y+ experience than UA and it's not close IMO. I'd put DL/AS above AA above UA and avoid G4, F9, NK. I'd have no problem trying B6 or MX if they worked with my routing and schedule. International I tend to choose non-NA carriers for better soft products.
 
Last edited:
Devil's Advocate said:
In general terms I think many travelers realize that Allegiant, Frontier, and Spirit are in one group, with American, Delta, and United in another, and Southwest doing their own thing. Like you I'm doubtful they can articulate what is different between airlines within each group or how they compare with B6 or AS.


AA, AS, & DL have a better domestic W/Y+ experience than UA and it's not close IMO. I'd put DL/AS above AA above UA and avoid G4, F9, NK. I'd have no problem trying B6 or MX if they worked with my routing and schedule. International I tend to choose non-NA carriers for better soft products.
Click to expand...
Someone is going to have to translate all of these airline codes. AS, G4 F9, NK, B6, MX?

I presume W/Y+ means premium economy class.

Anyway, since BWI is my home airport, I usually need to fly Southwest if I want to get a nonstop flight to most places.
 
Devil's Advocate said:
AA, AS, & DL have a better domestic W/Y+ experience than UA and it's not close IMO. I'd put DL/AS above AA above UA and avoid G4, F9, NK.
Click to expand...
Surprised that you put UA that low. They've been working on upgrading their fleet for a while now. I think they'll definitely surpass AA.
 
MARC Rider said:
I presume W/Y+ means premium economy class.
Click to expand...
Yes.

jiml said:
MX = Breeze?
Click to expand...
Yes. :cool: 👍

Cal said:
Surprised that you put UA that low. They've been working on upgrading their fleet for a while now. I think they'll definitely surpass AA.
Click to expand...
I put UA's domestic W/Y+ well below the equivalent product on AA, AS, and DL. This is relevant even when you book F/J since a delay, cancellation, or downgauge can bump you down to E+. There are areas where UA beats other airlines (TPAC frequencies, Polaris lounges, UR transfers, etc.) but in many ways I see them as the "Amtrak of airlines" and for the types of trips I take and places I'm likely to travel UA tends to be at or near the bottom of the legacy list. On the plus side UA is absurdly generous with travel credits, or at least they used to be.

(E+ = Economy Plus on United)
 
Last edited:
Another legitimate plus of United is their high number of international destinations.

I also find that Polaris, in my experience, is perhaps the most accessible ULH lie-flat class of all major international carriers. I’ve, on more than one occasion, had an economy or economy plus seat booked, where the upgrade to Polaris was under $1k at the airport or 12 hours beforehand, as opposed to a $6-8k outright initial purchase. If your initial fare is taken care of, this is a real treat.

Being from Boston, I’ve had a lot of experience with JetBlue. For regional or domestic stuff, they’re my favorite. And the fact they fly to Europe now is really great, though I have not yet taken advantage. Mint is a little pricey, but it’s a great product, easily on par with any other lie-flat.

I finally had the opportunity to fly Alaska Airlines last month. It was a nice experience. Not quite as good as JetBlue in my opinion, but given their low fares, I’d take it again if given a chance.
 
Cal said:
Surprised that you put UA that low. They've been working on upgrading their fleet for a while now. I think they'll definitely surpass AA.
Click to expand...
FYI: After more than one horrendous flight on UA, I swore I would never fly them again and I've kept my word. Avoid UA at all costs particularly if flying to or through Houston. While all the main lines have their problems, I prefer American. I haven't drunk the kool aid for Delta like so many others have but it's decent. I fly to BWI more than a couple times a year so I've been forced to take Southwest but I'm not a fan. Jet Blue and Alaska are all good airlines. I would never fly one of the cheapos ( ie: ULC). My 2 cents worth.
 
DetroitTed said:
FYI: After more than one horrendous flight on UA, I swore I would never fly them again and I've kept my word. Avoid UA at all costs particularly if flying to or through Houston. While all the main lines have their problems, I prefer American. I haven't drunk the kool aid for Delta like so many others have but it's decent. I fly to BWI more than a couple times a year so I've been forced to take Southwest but I'm not a fan. Jet Blue and Alaska are all good airlines. I would never fly one of the cheapos ( ie: ULC). My 2 cents worth.
Click to expand...
I too refuse to give United any of my hard earned money. Unfortunately when I fly for work my options are constrained by things like “price” and “city pairs” and I am sometimes forced to give United some of the taxpayers hard earned money. Overall I despise United as much as any person can dislike a corporation and I do my very best to avoid them.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top