Bi-level Long Distance (LD) fleet replacement RFP discussion H2 2024

[Johnny]

Since Stadler makes mostly aluminum trains, does this fact make them less likely to win (since Amtrak is requesting a stainless steel trainset)?

Also, I wonder how likely it is that Hitachi or Kawasaki win this contract since they do, in fact, make quality vehicles but it is also true that Amtrak has never ordered any equipment from them.

 

[Brian Battuello]

Re my earlier comment about Kawasaki, if they would toss in a bar car with snacks, I'd happily ride in a transit car for trips under 200 miles if it was cheap, fast and frequent. Would be nice if they faced the seats forward, though, and the FRA would probably make them take out the standee straps.

I believe this used to be called an interurban...

 

[Paniolo Man]

Well I'm back on the Stadler hope train. They just won UTA's LRV replacement with a steel designed vehicle meaning they plan to have steel car capacity in the US. I know well they are bidding, but solid plans for their expanded factory will help their bid quite a bit.

 

[thefirewarde]

They're not part of the Siemens monoculture that's been growing and they haven't recently fumbled/helped fumble a major Amtrak contract (Viewliner 2 and Avelia come to mind as "maybe you should deliver someone else's trains as promised before we try you again" programs). That puts them in rarified company.

 

[Johnny]

Well I'm back on the Stadler hope train. They just won UTA's LRV replacement with a steel designed vehicle meaning they plan to have steel car capacity in the US. I know well they are bidding, but solid plans for their expanded factory will help their bid quite a bit.

Congratulations to Stadler! (And I know that their Caltrain EMU trains have received great reviews).

It turns out that Hitachi is building a new rail factory in Maryland--which is a relatively short drive to Amtrak's headquarters in Washington DC. Does this possibly make it more likely that Hitachi could win the Superliner replacement contract, since Amtrak executives could frequently visit the new factory and check out the manufacturing of the new coaches?

 

[Steve4031]

Congratulations to Stadler! (And I know that their Caltrain EMU trains have received great reviews).

It turns out that Hitachi is building a new rail factory in Maryland--which is a relatively short drive to Amtrak's headquarters in Washington DC. Does this possibly make it more likely that Hitachi could win the Superliner replacement contract, since Amtrak executives could frequently visit the new factory and check out the manufacturing of the new coaches?

I think it would take much more than being near headquarters. They would have to submit a bid to address the needs expressed in the original order.

That original order was a pie-in-the-sky request. Have there been any changes since there have not been any bids?

 

[jis]

Congratulations to Stadler! (And I know that their Caltrain EMU trains have received great reviews).

It turns out that Hitachi is building a new rail factory in Maryland--which is a relatively short drive to Amtrak's headquarters in Washington DC. Does this possibly make it more likely that Hitachi could win the Superliner replacement contract, since Amtrak executives could frequently visit the new factory and check out the manufacturing of the new coaches?

Amtrak executives visiting a factory? Surely you jest. Or did you just forget to add a smiley?

 

[Johnny]

Jis,

Which two companies do you think are the most likely to win this contract?

 

[jis]

Jis,

Which two companies do you think are the most likely to win this contract?

I tend not to speculate on such. I try to share concrete information (that I am not constrained from sharing due to confidentiality agreements) and at present there is none that I have.

 

[Steve4031]

I tend not to speculate on such. I try to share concrete information (that I am not constrained from sharing due to confidentiality agreements) and at present there is none that I have.

This is why I always read Jishnu's posts. I know I am getting the most accurate information possible.

 

[jiml]

This is an innocent question not intended to start anything political. Has the money for the new Amtrak LD equipment already been allocated and is not revocable? Obviously you folks have an election coming shortly and I have to wonder if a change of leadership could impact any order. Drawing a parallel with our impending election and potential change of government, VIA's funding (and certainly capital purchases) will likely be high on the chopping block of the potential winners. What is the situation south of the border?

 

[jis]

MODERATOR'S NOTE: Discussion and speculation about the remaining life of Superliners has been moved to the following thread:

https://www.amtraktrains.com/threads/speculation-about-remaining-life-of-superliners.88137/

General discussion of possible better ways of handling equipment procurement has been moved to the following thread:

https://www.amtraktrains.com/thread...ng-procurement-of-equipment-for-amtrak.88136/

Please continue those discussions in these new threads and reserve this thread for discussing only the details of and progress of the actual current bi-level RFP that is out.

This thread has now been unlocked.

Thanks for your understanding, cooperation and participation.

 

[jis]

This is an innocent question not intended to start anything political. Has the money for the new Amtrak LD equipment already been allocated and is not revocable? Obviously you folks have an election coming shortly and I have to wonder if a change of leadership could impact any order. Drawing a parallel with our impending election and potential change of government, VIA's funding (and certainly capital purchases) will likely be high on the chopping block of the potential winners. What is the situation south of the border?

Technically speaking the money has not been committed until the actual order is placed and contract signed with the vendor.

In principle Congress can claw back (rescind) almost any funds that have not been committed. So at least theoretically the bi-level order could be in jeopardy. But from what we are hearing, there is at present bi-partisan support for LD trains, so there is some comfort in that. But one never knows for sure what happens in the big horse trading. But for now, people in the know believe the bi-level order to be relatively safe.

 

[Paniolo Man]

Technically speaking the money has not been committed until the actual order is placed and contract signed with the vendor.

In principle Congress can claw back (rescind) almost any funds that have not been committed. So at least theoretically the bi-level order could be in jeopardy. But from what we are hearing, there is at present bi-partisan support for LD trains, so there is some comfort in that. But one never knows for sure what happens in the big horse trading. But for now, people in the know believe the bi-level order to be relatively safe.

I heard a few times that bids were due in "Early November", do you know when specifically that might be?

 

[Paniolo Man]

For a lack of answer here I reached out and asked. The close date is 11/29. I wish they could get an award out by late January for obvious reasons, unfortunately that seems unlikely.

I fear this whole procurement is in peril.

 

[jadebenn]

We can only hope that the GOP Senators - being more supportive of the LD services than the NEC - stay the course. But I completely understand the pessimism.

 

[Paniolo Man]

We can only hope that the GOP Senators - being more supportive of the LD services than the NEC - stay the course. But I completely understand the pessimism.

I had a great discussion with Mike Christensen of URPA about it recently. The hope is that us in states with politically moderate congressional delegations can convince our federal delegates to preserve funding for LD projects based on the economic return in rural areas.

Support for LD is nonpartisan in rural areas where Amtrak is the only non-vehicular link to the outside world.

 

[Awesometrainz]

Okay so been thinking
Hitachi, Kawasaki, and standler are the three most likely contenders from what I can see though, I would not write off the Siemens and Alston but Siemens has a ton of other projects so a new bid for a new design does not seem like a big priority for them. And the Aclea liberties are still not in service yet .

 

[Johnny]

Okay so been thinking
Hitachi, Kawasaki, and standler are the three most likely contenders from what I can see though, I would not write off the Siemens and Alston but Siemens has a ton of other projects so a new bid for a new design does not seem like a big priority for them. And the Aclea liberties are still not in service yet .

You are implying that you think Hitachi is the most likely winner?