A couple of Downeaster questions for those in the know:
I'm planning to be in the area in late September and considering a day trip on the Downeaster from Brunswick to Boston and back. An overnight in Boston was a thought until I checked even mid-tier hotel rates near North Station, so a same-day return it is!
Does this route mostly run on time, and if so, is it likely that a train arriving into Boston is the same one to next depart northward? There is a considerable gap in the schedule should this "connection" be missed.
Is Business Class on this train worth the extra? Also, is there any scenery worth noting along the way, while adding bucket-list mileage to my Amtrak portfolio?
The Boston hotels are out-of-sight expensive. That's one reason I gave up trying to connect from the eastbound Lake Shore to the last Downeaster to Maine. If the LSL is more than a couple of hours late, there could be a $500 penalty.
Regarding the Downeaster, the same train sets that come southbound into North Station become the next northbound departure, so 680 becomes 681 and 682 becomes 683 and so on.
You can check the recent performance history on ASMAD, but in my experience the first two southbound trains, 680/690 and 682/692, are quite reliable, rarely more than 15 minutes late. The afternoon arrivals are a bit more dicey, with delays of 30-40 minutes not uncommon. I have occasionally seen one of the afternoon trains be so late that it delayed the next northbound departure, particularly 686, which only has about an hour before it has to become 687.
Regarding scenery, the nicest stretch in my opinion is right out of Portland. Heading south, you cross the Fore River and get a view of the city and then, after going through Rigby Yard, you head into the Scarborough marsh and feel that you are right at the edge of the ocean for five or 10 minutes until you reach Old Orchard Beach, where the station is within sight of the beach and the waterfront amusement park. In the summer it's fun to see the crowds jamming the streets in OOB, and then by mid-September it becomes like an eerie ghost town.
After Saco, you're away from the ocean for the rest of the trip, though you do pass some lakes in New Hampshire. Just past the Haverhill station, you cross the Merrimack River and then follow it southwest for about 10 minutes to Lawrence, where the train turns to the south and the river to the north.
The business class used to be only a $9 markup from coach; now it's $12 (edited to correct), but that still seems a bargain compared with BC on other Amtrak routes. When I took BC from Boston to Portland last, the attendant took our complimentary drink orders and served us at our seats before the cafe opened to coach passengers, which I really appreciated after a day of hoofing around Boston.