Eagle's Super Bowl Parade 2/14/25

Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum

Help Support Amtrak Unlimited Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Maverickstation

Lead Service Attendant
Joined
Mar 2, 2017
Messages
436
Location
Boston, MA (Eastie)
I don't get how closing stations, especially regional rail stations, expedites travel when larger than usual crowds are expected. 🤨Same number of people want to go to the celebration, but you've now concentrated them into fewer stations. And for the suburban stations (not Suburban Station :) ) you lose the parking capacity of the closed stations, unless you run shuttle buses from closed stations to open ones.
 
I don't get how closing stations, especially regional rail stations, expedites travel when larger than usual crowds are expected. 🤨Same number of people want to go to the celebration, but you've now concentrated them into fewer stations. And for the suburban stations (not Suburban Station :) ) you lose the parking capacity of the closed stations, unless you run shuttle buses from closed stations to open ones.
And the reduction of frequencies means the trains that do run are more crowded. Why??
 
The problem is that in ‘08, every piece of infrastructure in the city totally meltdown on the Phillies parade, when we tried to run the regular workday and the parade. Usually the system has a mix of 2-6 car trains running, and at any given moment most seats in the system are empty. When the pope came in 2015, they tried this scheme. They took all 300ish available cars, made 50ish 6 car train sets and ran this peak only express schedule. This resulted in on-time improvements, moved more passengers than just trying to make the weekday schedule work, improved the full seat/empty seat ratio, and accounted for labor shortages. It’s not perfect, but it’s what can be reasonably run. Yes some people get put in bad spots, but they also would if they tried to operate as normal and the system melted down and hour’s long delays, expressing due to overcrowding, and rolling cancellations started. There is neither the money, nor the equipment, nor the labor to run any beefed up weekday schedule.

The other dirty little secret is the city doesn’t want to have huge crowds downtown, but that’s a whole conspiracy rabbit hole.
 
Back
Top