I agree, Sarah. It's one of those "one-of" places. I've searched through all the review sites for great "New Orleans-ey" places, and Le Pavillon always comes up high on the list. That's one of the reasons I was disappointed with some of the things I experienced:
If this were a Motel 6 or a Holiday Inn, you'd never go back, would you?
The period decor is a HUGE selling point, and it works.
If this place is refurbished, with furniture and appointments that are up to snuff, it would be absolutely spectacular. I loved the period decor, as did Mrs. George. It was the best. The paintings, the carpets, the curtains were wonderful.
And, Sarah, you're right. The PB&J buffet is one of those truly special things that makes Le Pavillon a place you want to go back to. That, and the wonderful service and dining.
Fix the furniture, and spiffy up the service and you'll have a wonderful place. Five Stars.