I have no objection to anyone making a decent living based upon education, skill, talent and a good work ethic. Except for the kitchen staff the people working the dining cars are unskilled labor and should be compensated as such. In the private sector table servers are paid less than minimum wage but make a decent living by providing quality service that results in good tips.
If the private sector moved into the dining cars they would use restaurant labor that is paid the going rate and they will earn what they are capable of earning. Like it or not, fair or not, this is the way of the world. The janitor just doesn't get paid as well as other workers in a business.
Amtrak has a big problem on its hands now that Boardhead promised congress to have food service profitable or at the break even point in 2 years. What a disingenuous statement to make. You would have to be an idiot to believe this. This promise to congress will undoubtedly result in massive layoffs and poor or non-existent food service. Thanks to their leader, Amtrak has put themselves in a corner and something must be done.
My solution is to have private industry take over the food service on the dining cars for the free use of them. The food service would be responsible for everything including, menus, preparation, tableware, cleanup and maintenance. This has got to save Amtrak millions and while they bear the cost of transporting the car, it eliminates all other costs.
. Putting Amtrak food service people out of work is certainly not a good thing. We can argue what is right and just but the stage has already been set Changes are going to happen regardless, and other approaches will come into play. Its either this or no food service at all.